Letter To The Editor: We Should Determine If 'No Kill' Is A Misnomer

Letter to the Editor:

No Kill?

Madison County government’s move to embrace “No Kill’ seemed done for humane reasons. However, recent in depth studies by animal activists revealed unwanted and unintended consequences of ‘No Kill’ interventions. The special treatment of feral cats by humans may be compared to parents of a family providing special help to the ‘fair haired child’ to the detriment of siblings.

If you are a ‘No Kill’ advocate or a cat aficionado you might wish to read a recent article by Arie Trouborst, Phillipa D. McCormack, and Elvira Martinez Comacho entitled; “Ways in Which Domestic Cats Impact Wildlife”; dated February 4, 2020. The authors’ article details how worldwide “No Kill” interventions led to harm of non-cat species. For example, they found feral cats in ‘No Kill’ programs lead to killing of other species by unchecked hunting. Feral cats detrimentally preyed on local birds, mammals, and amphibians and reduced the food supply for indigenous predators like eagles or hawks. The ‘cute little kitties’ humans provided a favored status became cunning hunters released on other species in an unbalanced eco system. “No Kill” might create unintended outcomes for wild species as they get eaten alive by feral cats. Perhaps we should determine if ‘Madison County No Kill’ is a misnomer.

Respectfully,

Phil Chapman

Highland, IL

Opinions expressed in this section are solely those of the individual authors and do not represent the views of RiverBender.com or its affiliates. We provide a platform for community voices, but the responsibility for opinions rests with their authors.

More like this:

Illinois Monitors Apparent Natural Silver Carp Die-Off in Illinois River

Jun 28, 2026

IDPH Advises Precautions As Warm Weather Carries Increased West Nile, Rabies Risks

May 16, 2026

Bethalto Resident Released After Alleged Domestic Battery, Death Threat Against Officer

5 days ago

Severe Storms Force Evacuation At St. Clair County Animal Shelter

May 19, 2026

Alton Man Charged With Battering Officers After Disturbance At Hit-N-Run

Jun 5, 2026